Showing posts with label de Gaulle. Show all posts
Showing posts with label de Gaulle. Show all posts

12 July, 2022

Banned! Buried! Forbidden! Europe's Bill of Rights

 

Banned! Buried! Forbidden! Europe's Bill of Rights

EU Commission's Censorship from Jean Monnet to von der Leyen


Banned!

Seventy years have past since Jean Monnet chaired the first meeting of the European Commission in Luxembourg. It was then called the High Authority. It is the central innovation of the European Community of Coal and Steel. It brought peace to Europe for the first time in more than two millennia.




How? It provided the democratic and just means to adjudicate between coal and steel cartels, the national and multinational entities (greater than States) that incited Europe to seemingly endless wars. The High Authority was acclaimed as Europe’s Honest Broker.

Was it honest under Jean Monnet? No, not really. Today’s troubles stem from Monnet’s mistakes.

The first major act of the High Authority was to assemble a bureaucracy and make available the Treaty of Paris to the officials. This was the international agreement that defined their work, their relations with other institutions and their goals.

The officials were all given a bound copy of the Treaty with a black cover.

But Horror of horrors! It lacked one essential document in the Treaty.

Guess what Monnet left out?

Clue: Monnet was concerned about the autonomy of the Community and wanted to run the High Authority unhindered. To make his position clear, he wrote to the Council of Europe Secretary General just days after taking office.

On 1 August 1952, he wrote to Schuman’s former colleague, Jacques-Camille Paris, then Secretary General of the Council of Europe. Acting under Foreign Minister Schuman, he had negotiated the creation of the Council of Europe as a Director for Europe at the French Foreign Ministry.

Monnet wrote (on notepaper of the Planning Agency, not the High Authority!):

‘The role and nature of the Council of Europe are, as you are aware, wholly different from the European Community.’

This was one of the first shots in what became the battle between the two Schuman institutions. It set the two organisations on different paths when they should have been working together.

Robert Schuman had made this clear when in August 1950, just after he had launched the Schuman Plan for the European Community, he presented to the Council of Europe the outline of the Community institutions and how they would work together to reinforce Human Rights in Europe.

The first three Community treaties (Coal and Steel, Euratom, EEC) were all discussed in the Council of Europe. Monnet’s ill-judged action gave later politicians the unfounded belief that they could create treaties totally independently of human rights considerations.

They could override rejections in national parliaments. They could ignore referendums that rejected their drafts. They could install these fraudulent treaties lacking public support as if they were authentically democratic.

The least the public should expect is that Community treaties have full public support. It should be democratic. That is not the case for the like of the Lisbon/ Constitutional Treaties. They are imposed on the public against obvious pubic rejection. Brexit was the consequence of this Democratic Deficit.

Charlie McCreevy was European Commissioner 2004 to 2010.

How did this happen? Was the first treaty defining the institutions defective or was Jean Monnet as president of the High Authority responsible for the problem?

The missing Treaty

The Treaty of Paris contains eight documents besides the text describing how the institutions of the Community work together in the European Coal and Steel Treaty.

The Treaty of Paris is composed of:

1.       Text of the European Coal and Steel Community treaty, ECSCT ,

2.       The Charter of the Community or DĂ©claration commune,

3-5.       Three protocols on

  • privileges of officials,

  • the Court of Justice, and

  • the Council of Europe,

6-7.       French and German governmental letters on the Saar,

8 .      Convention dealing with initial and transitory measures.

Guess which Monnet (who was used to getting his own way) omitted from his little black book!

Was it the Protocol on the Council of Europe?

This would have been an impossible task. There were three protocols of equal weight legally. One gave the legal immunities of the officials as far as diplomatic privileges were concerned. A second defined the Court in the European Community system and how it should work. This shows the importance of protocols: the Court is defined by one of them. Thus to leave out the third protocol would be seen as contrary to justice and common legality. What Monnet did was to reduce its importance.

The Protocol’s aim was stated as to ‘establish ties as close as possible’ with the Council of Europe. ‘It was emasculated by the doggedness and obstinacy of Jean Monnet,’ said Paul Levy, the Director of Press and Information at the Council. But the essential survived, but often only in theory.

The Protocol described its relationship the Community as being one of a human rights guardian. It included, at first, shared membership of the two parliamentary Assemblies. Before they were elected, national parliaments delegated the Assembly members, Article 1. Thus if both had common personalities it was easy for them to raise human rights and transparency questions that might arise in the European Community in the Council of Europe. Action could be taken in the Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg.

The Protocol specified:

  • The High Authority and the Community Assembly should send their annual reports on their activities to the respective bodies in the Council of Europe, Articles 2 and 3.

  • The High Authority should inform the Council of Europe about the outcomes of recommendations it had given to the Community, (Article 4).

  • Joint work together was envisaged in Article 6.

Monnet could and did minimise these stipulations in practice.

What could not be avoided was the document equivalent to a Bill of Rights, written legally in the form of a diplomatic treaty. He tried to eliminate it by leaving it out completely.

The Community’s Bill of Rights

The Charter of the Community providing the public and all participants of the institutions to appeal to Courts of law about corruption, lack of transparency and fairness. Two courts were available for this: the European Court of the Community and the Court of Human Rights at the Council of Europe (for a further, higher appeal).

This was the document left out completely of the printed copies.

Why was the Charter so important for the public and too much for Monnet’s tastes? It provided a guarantee that the institutions like the European Parliament should be open like a national democratic parliament, and the Consultative Committees should elected and open and yes! the Council of Ministers should also be open too.

In other words, politicians and representatives to the institutions should be held responsible to their electors, a record should be kept of their proceedings and the public could choose whether they would ‘kick out the rascals’ who behaved in a dishonest and autocratic fashion. That does not happen in autocracies of the extreme Right and Left.

The European institutions would therefore distinguish themselves from the People’s Democracies of Soviet controlled eastern Europe. Or as we would say nowadays from North Korea where the government ruled by edicts of a one-party State.

What the Charter says

The Charter makes clear that the Community is only open to democratic States who accept the Convention of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. It describes how unity can be expanded in Europe through the Community system, not by creating a federal Super-State but by creating further Communities as the needs arise. They do not attack the basic sovereignty of the States but in fact add to their sovereign powers.

It restricts entry into the European Community to countries that are able to prove they have and retain fundamental freedoms like: freedom of speech — to criticise government — and freedom of assembly — to create their own parties and opposition movements able to criticise centralised one party States. They have freedom to own property, to create businesses etc.

Importantly they recognise the new constitutional form that is inherent in the Community system. It is neither an international organisation like a confederation such as NATO or the OECD, nor a federation like the USA or Canada. The Member States retain their own sovereignty. But the remarkable innovation is that these sovereign States agree by free assent to designate one institution, in this case the High Authority or European Commission, to have supranational or federal powers. As Schuman wrote the Community system lies midway between a centrally controlled federal system (or Super-State) and a confederal system where the State is unrestricted.

The Charter states:

In signing the treaty founding the European Community for Coal and Steel Community, a community of 160 million Europeans, the contracting parties give proof of their determination to call into life the first supranational institution, and consequently create the true foundation for an organized Europe.

The Community system has the means to bind the States in a way to organise key sectors (like coal and steel) or the nuclear industry in the case of Euratom, so that the common goal of eliminating intra-State war is achieved.

Thus a new hope for a peaceful future is created that encourages peace-enhancing collaboration and commerce across the entirety of the Community territory. Common laws and a means to justice in case of disputes cement the process.

Even before the work was set in motion, the virtues of the idea that inspired it had already aroused  in our countries and beyond its borders an extraordinary surge of hope and confidence.

Membership open to all as far as Russia

Schuman was asked about Russia when he made his Proposal on 9 May 1950 that all European countries (defined by membership of the Council of Europe) could become members of the European Community.

Could Russia become a member?

Schuman’s answer surprised many. ‘Yes of course!’

If Russia signed up to the above freedoms of expression and assembly then it would be welcome. That, incidentally would have made the monopoly power of the Communist party impossible. But it put Russia’s choice in stark relief. Did Russia want peace or want the monopoly of Communist control and ideological imperialism?

The European Coal and Steel Community could easily have been expanded to include Russia’s coal, gas and petroleum to the advantage of all.

Buried!

The Treaty Charter found no liking with Jean Monnet. It presented quite a different world view from his idea of creating a USA-style market in what would be a federal State of Europe.

It is questionable whether Monnet ever really understood the significance of the constitutional innovation that Schuman had initiated. The Community idea was like nothing that had ever occurred in history. The Community had just one federal element. It was neither a federation nor a confederation. It had democratic controls far more potentially powerful than any other previous constitutional arrangement of freemen.

Schuman was a constitutional lawyer of great international renown. He was educated in Luxembourg, Germany and France. He earned his doctorate in law at Strasbourg university. He called this third approach ‘a supranational Community.’ ‘Supranational’ is a term directly associated with his new constitutional idea. To help people comprehend the magnitude of political power and astounding novelty of this idea in constitutional history Schuman wrote a book about it, analysed it in legal terms, gave innumerable speeches and wrote many articles.

What did Monnet write? Little or nothing is in his archives. He made out to journalists that he was behind the idea of Community. This is a gross exaggeration. The drafts were written by Paul Reuter, Schuman’s jurisconsult in conjunction with Schuman and his Cabinet director, Bernard Clappier, a top grade financial expert who later became head of the Bank of France. Monnet was self-taught and had never gone to university.

Admittedly these drafts were written and discussed in Monnet’s offices. Why? Because the Foreign Ministry was full of Gaullists and nationalists, violently opposed to any concession to Germany or any other foreigner.

It is clear Monnet was never at the origin of the idea of a supranational Community. In his Memoires, he writes:

The High Authority was qualified as ‘supranational’ in the fourth draft {of the Schuman Declaration}. But I did not fancy the term and never fancied it. … Reuter made his contribution in this creative phase.’ p352.

Monnet later struck out the term supranational in a later draft. Reuter was a trusted legal aid for Schuman, a man of his confidence, who helped Schuman prevent officials at the ministry sabotaging his plans for European reconciliation.

Monnet later often told colleagues that he was wrong to agree to an authority above governments — thus he failed to understand what brought thousands of years of war! So Monnet learned little from Schuman.

Monnet had worked with Charles de Gaulle during the war. He owed his postwar position in government as the chief bureaucrat of the Planning Agency to de Gaulle. And de Gaulle was firmly against anything that opposed his idea of a nation-State of Napoleon or Charlemagne.

This may be another main factor why Monnet acted as he did and buried the Charter Treaty.

Forbidden!

Three Communities were created that set Europe on a new path for peace and prosperity. The last two, the Euratom treaty and the Economic Community were hurriedly signed in Rome in 1957.

The reason for haste was that Charles de Gaulle was about to seize power. Europeans knew that these treaties would not be signed by France once he was in control.

A decade of Gaullist power followed. De Gaulle tried to destroy the Communities and block any progress towards unity. He wanted to dominate a ‘Europe of the fatherlands’ by force of his power. His ministers boycotted the institutions for six months hoping it would break them. The Community turned out to be stronger than an autocrat in one Member State.

The Charter was not only buried deep in the archives of the French Foreign Ministry but the ideas of democratic and human rights control was sidelined and forbidden as de Gaulle fired up a war in Algeria to gain power and then attempted to douse the flames top establish his autocracy.

When de Gaulle was forced to retire following riots and insurrection, European politicians were left with a Community system without its vital Bill of Rights.

Some of these politicians were ministers under de Gaulle. They had lived through a decade of autocratic decision-making, closed door meetings without the public having a look-in on their own rights.

Politicians too often prefer to make decisions without public supervision. It makes their work easier and allows a moderate amount of corruption.

Then this became a major problem. Gaullist France used the Community as a private piggy bank. The Community’s Common Agricultural Policy got out of hand with more than 70 percent of the Community spent on subsidising farmers and paying for farm surpluses in storage.

Democrats forbid public supervision?

In April last year I wrote to Commission President Ursula von der Leyen asking that the Charter be published on the EU website and in the Official Journal as a founding document of the Community. Not having received a reply, I made a complaint to the European Ombudsman.

I still do not have an official reply from the President’s office, a year and a quarter later.

I also asked Commission, Parliament and Council representatives who launched the Conference on the Future of Europe to publish the document to aid discussion on democracy in Europe. They readily agreed.

The Conference on the Future of Europe is now past history. The Charter has still not been published in spite of reminders of the pledge to publish.

  • Has the legal service of the Commission put the Charter under a censoring interdict so it cannot be published on its website?

  • Is it too afraid of the legal implications of the Charter Treaty? If not why do Europeans not have their Bill of Rights published with other founding documents in the Official Journal?

  • Does this censorship prove that the Commission is now a confirmed autocracy?

  • Once the Charter is well known and published by historians and newspapers again, and seen on television and the internet, will the autocracy collapse of its monstrous hypocrisy?

31 December, 2020

Brexit, Giscard and half a Billion citizens denied Democracy

 1, January, 2021

Half a billion people are denied democracy. How can they fix it?

In December 2020, Brexit reached its multi-thousand page paroxysm. The documents, covering not just trade but identity, travel and nuclear war, have never been seen by Britons or by Continental Europeans. They will dominate our future for years ahead. Nearly every aspect of life will be dictated by these unseen bureaucratic inventions.

Behind this seizure of power by bureaucrats, lie years of deceit and duplicity by European leaders, subverting the most precious aspects of Europe’s newly gained heritage: democracy and peace.

That same month of December, ValĂ©ry Giscard d’Estaing, the draftsman the Constitutional Treaty, died at the age of 94 years. After having served as minister of finance under General de Gaulle, he had been, at 48 years, the youngest president of France in the tumultuous 1970s.

Among a life of many political milestones, what should be considered his greatest achievement? What does it tell us about Brexit?

Giscard typifies why Brexit happened. He shows the main problem facing Europeans in 2021. Open Democracy was systematically buried by politicians. They saw themselves as patricians of their own politburo. Taxpayers’ pennies became their personal pocket money. They wanted to net it and spend it as they wished. They wanted to decide how in private. A trillion euros to boot!

Giscard should be remembered as the co-author of the Constitutional Treaty, the antidemocratic forerunner of the Lisbon Treaty. He is also, surprisingly, the Statesman who exposed the hypocrisy and the legal Black Hole of the Lisbon Treaty. The change from a Community system of Robert Schuman to a neo-Gaullist system involved the destruction of fundamental human rights legislation and the ultimate exclusion of the United Kingdom from its secret councils.

It can be called a conspiracy against democracy. Giscard willingly participated and unwittingly exposed the fraud to the public in widely published syndicated press articles.

Post Brexit Pact

The UK-EU 1246 page agreement and its hundreds of ancillary documents actually uncover the fundamental question of European democracy that Giscard tried to hide.

It is deep down there.

What do Europeans mean by Democracy? Schuman designed five institutions to articulate this.

Europeans need to fire them up to work again.

Community System

The aim of the Community system was to stop war. No more, no less. First duty is to identify those people who want to make a profit from war. They shamelessly made money from spilt blood.

Then, secondly, identify the key sector. Schuman had made a deep analysis of coal and steel cartels who were also the Masters of the arms trade. They created an arms race at the turn of the century that led to World War One. They controlled major banks.

These and other international cartels made profits from WW2.

Schuman’s first Community created democratic institutions that brought such maleficent masters of war before criminal justice. It worked. War between Community Member States stopped in 1951 with the approval of the Treaty of Paris.

Further Communities were created to avoid atomic war and trade war.

Key Sectors

Note that the Community system is focused on an economic sector that has these lethal properties. It does not attempt to create a Constitution for Europe. It does not attempt to control people or governments. It provides instruments for the people to stop having internal, fraternal wars.

The positive result is that cross-border trade, innovation and specialisation can flourish. This provides an economic boost to the economy like no other measure.

Note: the Community system:

  • deals with one agreed sector at a time,
  • provides open, democratic institutions to agree to management.
  • It is not a top-down system,
  • nor does it create a United States of Europe based on government control. Nation States retain their sovereignty. People boost their freedoms.

 

Plot to destroy the Community of Europe

Who were its enemies? Who opposed the Community system of democratic cooperation in Europe?

  • Nationalists who said that no foreigner should influence their glorious national policy.
  • Gaullists who belong to the above category with the exception that de Gaulle should run the Continent, freed of so-called Anglo-Saxons, as its new Charlemagne. 
  • Federalists, idealist dreamers, who wanted to create a Federal United States of Europe in spite of centuries of history that showed that the European people would not vote for a new Constitution that replaced all their history and past achievements. Why was there support for the scheme for a European Constitution? Historically many plans were formulated over a millennium or more. All failed. The leaders wanted power. They forgot the people.
  • Fourthly were EuroCommunists who wanted to see a victory of the USSR over the USA. They could then set up a dictatorship of the European proletariat. They would be the new elite Politburo who would both rule and set up the new institutions of government. They would exclude both the Community system and the Council of Europe’s Human Rights Court. Altiero Spinelli was the most vocal euroCommunist activist. Spinelli’s ‘anti-fascist‘ plans have all the attributes of Communist disinformation. They would block Europe’s growth for generations and allow the USSR to catch up. What would the USSR desire most? Remove the economic motor of Europe, the EEC Common Market treaty, and replace it with something that obviously would not work, something that had been proved not to work for centuries. Remove Europe’s defensive mechanism in the Coal and Steel Community and Euratom. Block any criticism of ‘dialectic materialism‘ by reducing the Human Rights Convention to oblivion. Then Communist influence could spread from USSR-occupied East Germany and elsewhere and assert its power across all the Continent. That was Spinelli’s deceitful message. The Federalists were his ‘useful idealists’.

This was the plot for centralising power that was foisted on politicians starting with the 1986 Maastricht treaty. PM Margaret Thatcher later regretted she was fooled by these ideologues. She wanted a broader single market. They wanted top-down control via back-room, non-Community institutions dealing with Home and Foreign policies.

Limits to Delusion

A Constitution for Europe was then cooked up in the 1990s. It appealed to the vanity of many political leaders. The newly minted ‘European Summit‘ conference gave them a role and celebrity they did not have in the Community system. Like moths around a candle, they loved the bright lights of the TV cameras. They wanted to make their Summits permanent.

Many leaders supported some form of ‘United States of Europe’ where they, the leaders, ensconced in a ‘European Council‘, would decide the fate of the Continent.

How would it run? They didn’t know. Valery Giscard d’Estaing was given this dossier.

But such an inflexible constitution for Europe based on turning the people to serfs, obedient to their whims was doomed to fail. Giscard saw that expanding a national Constitution into a European one would not fly. France often changed its constitutions. Each time they had a referendum. But he knew that could not happen for all the Continent simultaneously. No Constitution plan of his would win the approval of all the people.

Hence he tried a different tactic, a treaty. Politicians tried to camouflage it. It was to be a Constitutional Treaty. Giscard was immediate and direct to debunk any illusion about it being a ‘Constitution.’

‘It is a treaty, like other treaties. Constitutional is an adjective.’ he said repeatedly. Legally it was like the Nice and Amsterdam treaties before it. The deception was in the name.

 

Genius of Schuman

Over a lifetime, Robert Schuman, the greatest political thinker of our time, analysed all these top-down plans. He saw why centuries of previous plans had all failed. They prioritised the means to give the maximum of power to the leaders. Schuman thought the freedom of individuals and their ability to fight corruption of leaders should be the first consideration.

In 1948 his government in France suggested something entirely different — a European Community founded on the rights of individuals and human rights. It reflects the natural law, not power politics.

The foundational document all national governments signed was to affirm that the Community was only open to countries where people were ‘free to choose‘.

That Charter of Interdependence is Europe’s Magna Carta.

He proved he was right in practice.

In the postwar atmosphere where all politicians, think tanks and diplomats thought wars and destruction would continually break Europe again in pieces, he carefully put forward a Plan the like of which the world had never seen before. It allowed two parts of Germany to reunify in peace. It kept the Communists, their fraudulent ‘People’s Democracies‘ and the USSR at arm’s length.

Europe enjoyed its longest period of peace and prosperity — ever.

Unlike all other plans, Schuman started with human rights.

EuroCommunist strategy

That proved the inadequacy of all previous, top-down plans. They were all shown to be impossible. Schuman called them all utopias, after the work of the Sir Thomas More. They assumed the leaders knew the way of peace. But they too were often corrupt and criminal. The rest had self-deceiving ignorance and egotism.

So what did Europe’s enemies do when the European Community not only created a peace system but the greatest prosperity they had seen in history? What happened to the Communists long-laid plans to occupy all of Continent rather than just bite off half of Germany and all of Eastern Europe?

Communists joined with ‘idealists‘ to persuade European politicians to take up a failed scheme that gave them more power. Thus they would expend their energies on a scheme that centuries of history had proved impossible: controlling the excesses of human nature.

The Communist parties in the West decided that if they could frustrate growth in the West and with the Communist capture of East Germany, Poland, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Bulgaria and Romania they could call on the power of the Soviet Union to do the rest.

Thus they joined forces with the utopian ‘Federalists’ to create a Constitution. After all, isn’t that how all nations asserted themselves on the world scene.

The plan of the EuroCommunists like Altiero Spinelli was designed to distract and diverge this movement in Western European plan to build peace and prosperity, based on Schuman’s European Community system.

Successful Foundation

There were three Communities that dealt with stopping wars:

  • European Coal and Steel Community, 1951 that allowed energy and steel resources to be used for legitimate defence and hauled industrial cartels that created the Arms Rings that led to World War One and Two.
  • Euratom, 1957, that made an internal atomic war impossible in the Community Member States, and help create energy independence.
  • European Economic Community, 1957, that with its Customs Union outlawed a Trade War between Member States.

Communists (the largest party in the French and Italian parliaments) working with nationalists saw that other such Communities were stopped. That included:

In spite the success of the first three communities, the federalists and the Communists drew together for support so that they should create something different. Both wanted a top-down approach, a Politburo.

For that they needed an apparatus that froze out the Council of Europe and its Human Rights for the citizens.

Look! No Poliburo!

All the above seven Communities were democratic. They all had one thing in common compared with the perverse plans of Gaullists, nationalists and Communists.

None of the Communities ever had any institution equivalent to a centralising European Council or a secretive conference of Heads of State and Government.

There was good reason why.

Power-hungry politicians saw things differently. They asked: where is the means where I can direct the levers of power according to my plans and my ideology? The Community is based on pragmatism, experimental wisdom. Centralising politicians and federalists want to engineer the population to fit their own preconceived ideology.

At the end of this road was a cul-de-sac called their Constitution.

That road led to both Hitler’s Reich and also the Dictatorship of the Proletariat by the USSR Communist Party. Europeans should have had more sense.

The Laeken Lark

The people should not listen uncritically to the conference communique of government politicians. For free people to allow such self-appointed leaders to claim undefined authority in another sphere is a big mistake.

It was not the way the Communities were fashioned. Goals and means were defined in open debate in the Council of Europe and other European institutions that Schuman had had a hand in forming.

In 2001, the ‘Heads of State and Governments’ — a Gaullist invention — met behind closed doors at Laeken, Belgium. The 75-year old Giscard was chosen by the federalist Belgian Prime Minister Guy Verhofstadt and his colleagues to lead.

Giscard had grand ideas. He was not a popular choice.

Reality eventually dawned on the project framers. A Constitution requires not only a document but public assent. No State was willing to give up its own national powers and subjugate its history to destruction by others. Some were formerly enemies. No State was willing to renounce its own constitution to be a cog in a European one.

Neither the governments nor the peoples were ready for such a move. No one in Europe saw the faintest hope of all the people of Europe assenting to any such document in a public referendum.

The Treaty Fraud

So they changed the target. They created a fraud. They decided to create top-down control by subterfuge. They would use the same method that Schuman had used to obtain the three Communities: treaty negotiation.

Unfortunately for them it was legally and operational unsuitable to create a Constitution. For a start, a Community was subject to the Strasbourg Court of Human Rights. Schuman designed that to protect individual citizens from such political abuse. A treaty requires popular assent.

Giscard was forced to turn the ‘Constitution‘ into a ‘treaty‘. A re-write of the EEC would demolish it and replace it by a take-over text.

Would this pass public scrutiny?

No. The French rejected it. Then the Dutch did the same with more force. The line-up of Member States ending with the UK looked likely to do the same. So the leaders called for a pause in the referendums.

Reaction of the ‘democratic’ leaders?

So what did Giscard think of ‘government of the people by the people and for the people‘?

‘The rejection of the Constitutional treaty by voters in France was a mistake that should be corrected,‘ Giscard declared, in London of all places on 28 February 2006.

He said that a second attempt at forcing it through should be made after the French elections of 2007, disdainful of the fact that other countries had or were about to vote it down. This is a typical Gaullist idea that treats the less-populated countries as ‘children’ needing France’s guidance.

As for countries with larger populations like United Kingdom, should any one let them have a referendum? Everyone knew the result in advance.

The European Council Con

European leaders were not willing to let a further promotion to their power over the people go away. So behind closed doors again, they decided they would keep the condemned ‘Constitutional Treaty‘ but give it another name.

They would also disguise its shape. They presented something that did not look like a Constitution or a Treaty. It was plain gibberish. It was a list of amendments to the already existing EEC treaty. ‘Remove the first sentence in the third paragraph and replace it with the following… etc’

A document that no one could understand! It was a deliberate policy. Those who authored it said so. And there would be no referendums if that could be prevented.

What did the new treaty — the present Lisbon Treaties — look like when it was presented to the public in 2007? It would be a list of disjointed amendments to the existing EEC treaty.

People protested.

It made no difference.

The Irish insisted on a referendum.

Horror of horrors.

They voted NO.

It made no difference.

They were told to vote again until they said Yes.

Other Europeans who were fiercely against it were ignored. Prominent among the Resistance were the British. A referendum for them was ruled out. Why? Giscard knew the answer. Both to why a referendum should be ruled out and what the answer would be if they had one.

The British government tried to clamp down on any decisive public voice on the incomprehensible draft. They had enough of a majority to prevent it going any further. Unlike the Irish, there was no constitutional right to have a referendum if some autocrat wanted to change centuries-old custom and tradition. Parliament dictated the outcome. And independent MPs had now been bridled by the party ‘whips’.

Other Member States used their parliamentary majorities to force the unpopular, undemocratic Lisbon Treaty through without asking the people. The Hungarians, for one, did it so rapidly practically before they had received the treaty in Hungarian.

So the Lisbon Treaty was not only the twin of the Constitutional Treaty that had been rejected but it was forced into being by underhand, undemocratic methods.

That makes it is obvious why the Community system is different. It is democratic. The EU is not. The Community does not have a European Council as part of its institutions.

Imagine, the politicians in the European Council, acting as usual, behind closed doors, deciding that they should bring in a dictatorship of a new de Gaulle or a new Napoleon. Maybe the German government was led by someone who admired Hitler. He had strong-armed the other less powerful States to follow his lead. De Gaulle tried to bring in such a system by changing the European Commission into a political secretariat. His Fouchet Plan failed.

Once politicians agree in private they act like a cartel and spread mischief. As all the government leaders in the European Council must by definition have a majority in their own parliaments, they could get them all to agree to such a proposition. National democrats would be told (as they were in fact), ‘you must pass this because it has been democratically decided in the (secret) European Council, with our other democracies.’

So Europe ends up with a pseudo-democratic dictatorship.

Without such a secret political cartel-like European Council, the European Community was able to deal with the problems of economic cartels. But who knows who was influencing various heads of government? Their party or they themselves might be politically beholden to a lobbyist group, or even a power like Chinese Communists. An economic or financial cartel may control or blackmail the political cartel.

A political cartel is called a Politburo.

No Referendum, Brexit neutralised

Then Giscard let the cat out of the bag.

 

Giscard admitted that the Constitutional treaty had been written by politicians alone. They came from the European Parliament, national parliaments and governments. No mention of ‘ordinary people‘.

He wrote: ‘The resulting draft constitution was a new text and replaced all previous treaties.‘

That was exactly the aim of the EuroCommunists and other politicians who favoured a top down Politburo to rule Europe, rather than a broad democracy of free people.

But the Constitutional Treaty was brought down by the people. How did this corpse get revived? Giscard was quite frank. It was less the politicians themselves but the bureaucrats, the lick-spittle, unaccountable plotters inside the European Council.

‘For the Treaty of Lisbon the process has been very different. It was the legal experts of the European Council who were charged with drafting the new text. They have taken the original draft constitution, blown it apart into separate elements, and then attached them, one by one, to existing treaties. The treaty of Lisbon is thus a catalogue of amendments.

It is impenetrable for the public.’

He added:

‘There are, however, some differences. Firstly the noun “constitution” and the adjective “constitutional” have been banished from the text, as though they describe something that is inadmissible.’

European flags bedeck the Berlaymont

All mention of the symbols of the EU had been suppressed, including the flag and the European anthem. This was done because the British among others objected that the aim was to create a European State. The effect of this ‘suppression‘ was more theoretical than practical as we can see today.

The Obvious No

Giscard concludes by saying the changes in the Lisbon Treaty and the Constitutional Treaty that he fathered are minimal.

But when the public had a half a chance to give their opinion at the perversion of democratic justice, the treaties were rejected. So Giscard is making a plain admission that the European political class is trying to ‘fool the people.’

Why were no referendums allowed when the Lisbon Treaty was forced through parliaments controlled by these unscrupulous political cartels?

Giscard is also quite frank. It was to stop the United Kingdom having a referendum on the Treaty itself. That would sink the whole project because everyone knew the British with their traditions of democracy would not stomach it. So the British would have to forgo their promised referendum. And so would everyone else (except the irascible Irish who would be told to vote twice or more until they agreed.)

The voice of the people cannot be bottled up for ever. The British never got their referendum on the obnoxious Lisbon Treaty. They got one on something totally different. That was Article 50 of the Treaty. But that is invalid because a referendum cannot be held on article in an illegitimate treaty. The treaty itself requires a referendum to activate it. Without it the treaty cannot be recognized in constitutional law.

 

The End of Democratic Europe?

Is the exit of the United Kingdom the end of British participation in European democracy?

Not at all. We have just reached the intermediate step, the painful and avoidable intermediate step, foreseen in the book: Don’t Brexit, Fix it! Copies of a version of this book were given to Prime Ministers Theresa May and Boris Johnson as well as the French and German leasers and President von der Leyen of the European Commission.

  • Brussels needs to have open government as the treaties actually say.
  • The British need to act as democrats when they cross the Channel and not go along with autocratic neo-Gaullism.

Written in 2016 just after the illicit 23 June referendum, the book says that Europeans have two alternative paths. They can enter a long period of ‘Painful Negotiation first‘. Or they can clarify Human Rights issues first. Treaties need to be openly analysed and discussed by the independent Council of Europe. All Community treaties were. Europeans need to reassert their Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms in the Strasbourg Court of Human Rights.

  • Is secret government, installed against the public voice legitimate?
  • Are several thousand pages of the post-Brexit pact, dumped on the public on 24 December 2020 legitimate?
  • Should the public be able to decide on these papers which will affect not only all trade but every aspect of their lives?
  • Who will be the judge and jury of all these thousands of outcomes?

This is precisely the reason Robert Schuman initiated the Council of Europe — to safeguard Europeans from autocrats.

It was a Frenchman, Jacques Abbadie who wrote in 1684:

One can fool some people, or fool all in some places and times, but one cannot fool all people in all places and ages.